Viet Cong’s Libertarian Appeal

Reading Vietnam at War by Mark Bradley, which is a brief but excellent survey of the period of Vietnamese decolonization (1945-1975) from the point of view of the Vietnamese, I encountered a particularly interesting passage:

“By some estimates the NLF controlled as much as half the population in southern Vietnam by 1963.

The reasons so many people came to support the Front so rapidly varied. For many peasants, the Diem government failed to assure a minimal level of well being and safety for their families while the NLF appeared to do so. Middle, poor, and landless peasants (trung, ban, and co nong) found little to like in Diem’s land reform efforts. In deference to the regime’s landlord (dia chu) base of support, it only redistributed land when holdings exceeded 250 acres, forced those who received land to pay for it, and tolerated land rents at 25 to 40 per cent of output. By contrast the NLF’s land reform programme avoided the excesses of the northern land reform in the mid 1950s and returned to the moderate DRV policies of the 1940s. It set maximum rents at 15 per cent, limited total landholding to 15 acres, and redistributed land at a nominal cost. Similarly, the Diem government’s regressive tax policy protected wealthy interests while the NLF’s more progressive taxation, a return to earlier norms based on the ability to pay, eased the burden on rural peasants.”

So for the peasants of Sout Vietnam the appeal of the National Liberation Front (the Viet Cong to Americans) lay in that it enacted lower charges on them than the combination of the Saigon government and the government-backed landlords had done and furthermore addressed the problem of land theft by feudalistic landlords by dispossessing them in favor of the legitimate owners — the tenant farmers. Additionally, while for the ARVN draftees a longer leave of absence was exceptionally hard to get by, the NLF would normally release its cadres for planting and harvest seasons so their fields could be tended to. In other words the reason the Communist-led NLF could win the support of the social class that would grant it most of its strength was in large part due to it demonstrating a greater practical commitment to the ideals of low taxes, landed peasantry and personal liberty than the nominally capitalist-aligned government in Saigon.

~ Marko

Tagged: , , ,

4 thoughts on “Viet Cong’s Libertarian Appeal

  1. Neodoxy 11/20/2012 at 21:20 Reply

    It would be interesting if you wrote more about this. It would be especially interesting to see how far corporatism has gone towards promoting communism, and how far populist uprisings in the past have utilized libertarian ideals.

    • Marko 11/26/2012 at 22:02 Reply

      Well, for me the point is the NLF like most organized movements of the past was one that had both positive and negative aspects. But it was undeniably an organization with mass support, so I am happy to stumble upon information that hints to it being massively supported for its positive aspects, rather than for its negative aspects.

      I am not really interested in making an apologetic for the Viet Cong, but more so for the common people who got behind it. Not that they need one, but it’s not like there’s anything wrong with redundancy.

  2. Andris Birkmanis 11/20/2012 at 21:30 Reply

    Could you provide a pointer to the history of the land theft?

    • Marko 11/20/2012 at 22:59 Reply

      It’s somewhat unclear as many sources assign the responsibility almost exclusively to the French such as here, when it should have been clear the situation preceded them. It seems Vietnam had always been a feudal society with the French period then reshuffling, to a degree, membership in the landlord elite and intensifying the exploitation with further expropriations.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: